It is commonly accepted that, insofar as we are social beings living inside a community structure, there are two kinds of responsibilities we manufacture for ourselves. Pragmatic, need-based, consumerist responsibility is one of those kinds of action. Acquiring goods, furthering your job, this need manifests itself in the physical realm. The other kind of need is a moral or civic responsibility we feel we have for other human beings; the drive to do something 'more', the sense of duty to help those who are less fortunate.
A problem I see is that in the current socio-economic system in place, the two acts of consumerism and charity have been synthesizes into one all-included package. With our consumerism, we are also buying into the idea that every 5 cents in my cup of coffee helps starving children, and 20 cents goes to a struggling farmer, and so on and so on. The implicit charity embedded in our consumerist actions promotes a kind of moral laziness; your ethical duties come all included in your consumerist package.The system is designed to fufill the needs it creates. Rather than being an opposing force, a metaphysical check and balancing system, or a healthy backdrop upon which our pragmatic consumerism takes place, our moral responsibility has become completely absorbed by capitalism.
Capitalism has the uncanny ability to absorb everything that opposes it. This wouldn't be so bad if the kind of things we felt as human beings ethically responsible for, poverty, starvation, human suffering, weren't given conditions of capitalism. It is thus a short circui Capitalism gives us solace by assuring us that consumers are helping those left fortunate all the while propigating the disease; in reality the system of capitalism itself produces the causes that give rise to suffering it is supposedly looking to help alleviate. The 'charity' is a byproduct of profit, profit is the key factor, and yet we're feeding off this received charity by allowing it to excuse us of active moral duty.
Rather than addressing every issue and tending to every moral responsibility through the lenses of free markets and capitalism, first we must reexamine the way we think about the relationship between consumerism and suffering, because as the coffee shops try to market their salvation for 2 dollars a cup, we need to think about the system we are buying into with that two dollars first. Is it honest? Is it just? Is it sustainable?
TRAGEDY THEN FARCE
------------------------------------------T-R-A-G-E-D-Y---T-H-E-N---F-A-R-C-E----------------------------------------------
Welcome
Tragedy Then Farce is focused on constructively battling the illnesses our age through creativity, curiosity, and communication. If you want any higher quality copies of my photographs to download, just let me know and I'd be happy to oblige. Welcome.
A Philosophy and Photography Blog
--------------------------------P--h--i--l--o--s--o--p--h--y-----A-n-d-----P--h--o--t--o--g--r--a--p--h--y---------------------------
Sunday, April 3, 2011
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Wonderful 4th picture!
ReplyDeleteNice blog.
Following.
like the desgin of ypur blog, wonderful :)
ReplyDeleteYou have a really strong point there. I feel happy to say that though I have fallen for that "every 5 cents goes to a starving child" advertising, which it pretty much is, I have taken the liberty to do my own charity work and donations. It really isn't the fault of the system, in this case capitalism, but the fault of the people. Great opinion; thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteI agree, charity and eco-friendliness has become dumbed down to a simple marketing-ploy. Capitalism is a dangerous beast :x
ReplyDeletelove the photography..
ReplyDeleteand i like what you're saying in that post.. at least if my interpretation is correct. i prefer to see the results of whatever type of charity i'm handing out. i used to hold back cause of a strong belief that what they take on side a isn't what's given to the more needy side b..
ya, really digging your style. daily reader here
ReplyDeleteI agree. Also, I really think your photos are amazing.
ReplyDeleteLove that photography man, im jealous
ReplyDeleteUsing charity as a marketing scheme just doesn't seem that effective. Yes, it is fairly common now, but does it really swing people to make that purchase so they feel better about themselves? Advertisers will hit on absolutely everything possible, but to me at least that doesn't signal a flaw in the underlying economic system.
ReplyDeleteNonetheless, you have a thought provoking take on it.
@ Badd
ReplyDeleteThe critical systemic flaw isn't that it can be used as a marketing scheme as much as this kind of instant false gratification promotes a kind of laziness. I don't have to go pursue my civil ethical duty, I'm already 'giving back' through my consumerism.
I love the pictures, but i dont fully agree with your view on capitalism.
ReplyDeleteexcellent photographs
ReplyDeleteI hate when companies try to guilt people into buying something because a very small percentage will go to charity.
ReplyDeleteA very powerful point.
ReplyDeleteIf you're going to do charity - real charity - it usually takes more than simply donating a few coins and hoping someone else will do something.
Volunteer, befriend a person in need, go to Africa and teach for free. Those are things that are more likely to have an effect.
Even though, ultimately, poverty is actively perpetuated for the benefit of our economies.
wonderful opinion
ReplyDeletei love the new pics!
ReplyDeleteI love so much the first ones and the last.
ReplyDeleteI hate the unfairness of the world, i buy fair trade items to help do my share,not saying this is enough but if everyone does it a significant difference will be made
ReplyDeletewow you ahve some nice pics!
ReplyDeleteThe whole charity thing is terrible these days, and I feel too mcuh is probably spent on their advertising. That could be going to a better cause.
ReplyDeleteLike the angles of the picture. Very well done
ReplyDeleteThe castle photo makes me want to go on vacation badly! haha. Following!
ReplyDeletelot to think about upon reading this post. great photography as well.
ReplyDeleteawsome pics
ReplyDeletefantastic post, really... you're a good writer
ReplyDeleteThats a very interesting way to look at it. I am beginning to distrust capitalism the more I learn about government.
ReplyDelete"Capitalism has the uncanny ability to absorb everything that opposes it. This wouldn't be so bad if the kind of things we felt as human beings ethically responsible for, poverty, starvation, human suffering, weren't given conditions of capitalism."
ReplyDeleteIt's depressing once I realized "capitalism" is said best economical structure... But it's true. If there's a winner in the world, someone else is losing. If I make $100, someone just lost $100.
I hate Capitalism at times, but when I'm making money - LOVE IT
ReplyDeletenot bad man, not bad at all
ReplyDeletemc me
I agree with many of the things you said, especially the part about capitalism absorbing everything.
ReplyDeletezizek is all over the place in this post. nice thoughts, jack. have you seen this RSA animation? basically talks about what you address here--really interesting stuff.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hpAMbpQ8J7g
-grant
I love this
ReplyDeletecool pics bro
ReplyDeleteThese are some wise words my man, it is clear that you care. The biggest problem though is how do we change that system
ReplyDeleteDiggin' the photos!
ReplyDeleteVery interesting post,nice blog. Following¡¡
ReplyDeleteWonderful pictures, blog and post! 1+ follower.
ReplyDelete1st photo great! One of best what i ever seen!
ReplyDeleteAwesome 2nd photo and the last one. Following
ReplyDeleteThat was a fun read, I'll be sure to see what you do next. Follow me at http://floridaweddinginformation.blogspot.com/
ReplyDeletewow, nice pictures!
ReplyDeleteI liked the 8th, nice blog :)
ReplyDeleteI love the cool earthy feel.
ReplyDeleteVery interesting, while I think capitalism is by far the worst of the evils, its no perfect society..
ReplyDeleteExtremely well written. Nice pics too!
ReplyDeleteI love the feel of everything here!
ReplyDeleteI'm not really into philosophy, but your pics are just awesome. Where is the castle in the last pic?
ReplyDeleteWicked pictures. The one with the basketball hoop is really top artsy. Is there no way to enlarge them ?
ReplyDeleteThese are really good man, keep it up.
ReplyDelete@Manhood88. I have full sized copies of all of these pictures, give me an email and Ill send you whatever you want.
ReplyDelete@Trolske
ReplyDeleteThe Castle is at Atlantic College, it is the second oldest Castle in Wales, and the third oldest in the UK.
i like your blog. keep up the good work
ReplyDeleteYou do raise a very good point and I also love the photography!
ReplyDeletethat was rly deep
ReplyDeleteyou're getting a fallow for sure
Great post man, I'm on the same level (sorta) with my blog...we could RUN THE WORLD.
ReplyDeleteLooks impressive dude. Will follow.
ReplyDeleteI hate those type of marketing ploys. I'm not too into philosophy, but that was interesting to read.
ReplyDeletecapitalism conquered the soviet union and its about conquered the usa as well, great post
ReplyDeletefollowed! sick photos!
ReplyDeleteI think capitalism is taking everything over, nice pictures by the way.
ReplyDeleteReally nice quality pictures, and I enjoyed reading your blog. Well done!
ReplyDeleteGreat to think about. Love the art
ReplyDeleteReally nice pics there!
ReplyDeletewow, you're a great writer.
ReplyDeletedon't ever stop
Loving the photos.
ReplyDeletevery neat pics :3
ReplyDeleteVery strong points here.
ReplyDeletenot sure there are just two kinds of responsibilities we manufacture for ourselves.
ReplyDeletefor all i know may be an infinite list of responsibilities...and they just seem to multiply like rabbits on top of me the older i get.